Skip to main content

Indian manufacturer renew 33-year legal battle against UBA

Akin Kuponiyi

UBA

An Indian-based manufacturer and exporter, D S Dave through its Nigerian appointed Attorney ROFRIS Investment and Trust Limited has renewed its 33-year legal battle against United Bank for Africa PLC over breach of contract.

In an amended statement of claim filed before a Federal High Court in Lagos, southwest Nigeria by a Lagos lawyer, Barrister Ade Oyebanji, it was alleged that sometimes in 1983 a customer of UBA, Kemson Trading Stores ordered for importation of Agricultural machines from D.S. Dave on the 28 of December, 1983 with the bank issuing a letter of credit in favour of the plaintiff while Kemson Trading Stores paid the bank the sum of 38,000 pounds being the cost of the goods ordered for by Kemson Trading Stores from D.S.Dave.

Upon the issuance of letter of credit by UBA., in favour of the plaintiff, the goods were released to Kemson Trading Stores.

However since the goods were released to Kemson Trading Stores since January 1984, UBA has failed, neglected and refused to remit to the plaintiff the sum of 38,000 pounds under the letter of credit.

The plaintiff said it made several effort from his base in India and on so many occasions had to travel to Nigeria to recover the money but without result.

Thereafter the plaintiff appointed Rofris Nigeria Limited as its attorney to help him recover the money.

The attorney contacted the bank who referred the matter to the Debt Management of the Central Bank of Nigeria, after several correspondences and visits to the Debt management Office in Abuja, the Attorney was told that the plaintiff ‘s claim was rejected by reconciliation bank, that is Central Bank of Nigeria because there was “no importer submission “during the refinancing exercise which was concluded in March, 1988, whereas it was the duty of the bank to submit all relevant documents relating to the transaction to the Central Bank of Nigeria and it was as a result of the failure of the bank to do same that the sum due to the plaintiff was not refinanced.

The plaintiff states that there have been several meetings and correspondences between the plaintiff and the bank in the past years to demand for the money due to him but the bank refused to pay the said sum of 38,000 pounds.

Consequently, the plaintiff claims against UBA are as follows: An order of the court directing UBA to pay the said sum of 38,000 pounds with interest at the rate of 21 per cent from January, 1984 until March, 2004 and thereafter at the same rate until final liquidation. General damages in the sum of N9,500,000.

However in the statement that the defence filed by the law firm of Udo Udoma, Below-Osagie on behalf of the bank, UBA while denying almost all the arguments of the plaintiff, stated that Kemson Trading Stores, the importer deposited the sum of N41,000.which was the naira equivalent of GBP 38,000 pounds as at December, 1983 but failed during the refinancing exercise to submit to reconciliation bank the requisite import documents to March the identity and claims of the plaintiff which would have led to the refinancing of the fund and subsequent remittance to the plaintiff as established in the letter of credit

Consequently, the bank states that the action of the plaintiff is misconceived, frivolous, an exercise of gold digging, vexatious and an abuse of court process of the court and ought to be dismissed with substantial cost.

The presiding judge, M S Hassan has adjourned till 29 June, 2016 for continuation of hearing.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Court grants Fani-Kayode N50m bail

Fani-kayode sandwiched by EFCC officials Justice James Tsoho of the Federal High Court Abuja on Thursday granted a N50m bail to former spokesman of the Goodluck Jonathan Campaign Organisation, Chief Femi Fani-Kayode. Fani-Kayode was arraigned by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) on a five-count charge of money laundering to the tune of N26m. Fani-Kayode is the sole defendant in the fresh charges numbered, FHC/ABJ/CR/140/2016. The EFCC accused the defendant of diverting 26 million Naira allegedly received from the ONSA while Sambo Dasuki was in office. The anti-graft agency also accused him of handling the said N26 million without going through financial institution as required under the Money Laundering Act. The embattled former minister is already facing 17-count charge of money laundering before the Lagos Division of the court, along with a former Finance Minister; Nenadi Usman, Danjuma Yusuf and a firm; Joint Trust Dimension Nigeria Limited. They were charg...

Pope not involved in Colombian peace deal- Vatican

Pope Francis Pope Francis has turned down a request to play a role in the peace deal between the Colombian government and the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) rebel group. The Vatican in a statement issued on Wednesday in in Vatican City said that an invitation was sent to his Holiness in early August to appoint a representative to participate in the committee that selected the judges for the talks. The statement said that though Pope Francis supported the peace process, he, however, reiterated that he would not get involved in Colombian peace deal. It said that Pope was praying for the enlightenment of the hearts and minds of those who were called to promote the common good of the Colombian nation. A deal was announced last week, putting an end to five decades of internal conflict between government forces and the FARC rebels. The agreement, which needed to be ratified through a referendum in Oct. 2, would entail setting up a special court to grant amnesties or pu...

Man docked for defiling 9-year-old girl

magistrate-court A 33-year-old man, Godwin Otobo, was on Monday docked at a Surulere Chief Magistrates’ Court in Lagos.For allegedly defiling a nine-year-old girl, ‎Otobo, who lives at No. 10, Borrow Pit St., Sangotedo-Ajah area of Lagos, was said to have defiled the underage girl whose parents also reside in the same compound. The Prosecutor, Sgt. Anthonia Osayande, told the court that the accused committed the offence at about 9.00 p.m. sometimes in September. “The accused defiled the girl in the night when she was fetching water.‎ “The offence contravened Section 137 of the Criminal Law of Lagos State, 2011,’’ Osayande told the court. The accused pleaded not guilty to the one-count charge of defilement. Ruling on a bail application filed by the accused, Chief Magistrate Ipaye Nwachukwu, granted him bail in the sum of N500,000 with two sureties in like sum. She said one of the sureties must be a property owner in Lagos State, while the other must be a civil servant on grade...