Skip to main content

Court frees two men after 5 years in prison custody

The gavel of justice

The gavel of justice

An Enugu High Court on Thursday freed two men, Emmanuel Eze and Chinedu Nnaji, for want of evidence by the prosecution after five years in prison custody, charged with robbery.

The accused persons were arrested on September 11, 2011, for allegedly robbing a 73-year-old man, Mr. Ephraim Ani and two other victims of their belongings with weapons at Amagu Obeagu in Enugu.

Ani had claimed that the accused persons robbed him of his money, phones from his children and took away one of his cutlasses.

According to him, it was when they left his premises that he climbed a mango tree in his compound around 1.30 a.m. and saw the two accused persons and four others that attacked him.

He further said that the accused were later apprehended by soldiers of 103 Battalion, Gariki, in Enugu, who thereafter, handed them over to the Awkunanaw Police Station in Enugu South Local Government Area.

Items recovered from the accused persons, according to police, were wrappers, torchlight, three wrist watches, four Nokia phones and a Samsung phone.

The presiding Judge, Justice Eno Oluedo, said that the prosecution counsel failed to tender items recovered from the accused persons as evidence before the court.

Oluedo said that the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.

“The prosecution failed to prove if the accused persons were robbers, participated in the said robbery or were arrested with gun and other dangerous weapons.

“Evidence needs to be proven and reliable; I doubted the evidence of the complainant who said he climbed mango tree by 1.30 a.m. when the incident occurred, to know the people that robbed him.

“The second complainant never said that the items recovered from the accused persons were hers and the military who arrested the accused never testified in court.”

Oluedo said that the evidence from the prosecution witness, Mr. Emmanuel Ugwu, showed that there were loopholes in the investigation.

“Upon examination, truth, corroboration, possible confession and consistence are the greatest ingredients.

“There is nothing outside the confessional statement from the accused to show that they were true and no fact to show that the accused robbed the complainants.

The judge ruled that the investigation was conducted poorly and the evidence by the prosecution was a mere speculation which the court will not rely upon.

She, therefore, discharged the two accused persons from all criminal charges.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Court grants Fani-Kayode N50m bail

Fani-kayode sandwiched by EFCC officials Justice James Tsoho of the Federal High Court Abuja on Thursday granted a N50m bail to former spokesman of the Goodluck Jonathan Campaign Organisation, Chief Femi Fani-Kayode. Fani-Kayode was arraigned by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) on a five-count charge of money laundering to the tune of N26m. Fani-Kayode is the sole defendant in the fresh charges numbered, FHC/ABJ/CR/140/2016. The EFCC accused the defendant of diverting 26 million Naira allegedly received from the ONSA while Sambo Dasuki was in office. The anti-graft agency also accused him of handling the said N26 million without going through financial institution as required under the Money Laundering Act. The embattled former minister is already facing 17-count charge of money laundering before the Lagos Division of the court, along with a former Finance Minister; Nenadi Usman, Danjuma Yusuf and a firm; Joint Trust Dimension Nigeria Limited. They were charg...
Post a Comment
Read more

Pope not involved in Colombian peace deal- Vatican

Pope Francis Pope Francis has turned down a request to play a role in the peace deal between the Colombian government and the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) rebel group. The Vatican in a statement issued on Wednesday in in Vatican City said that an invitation was sent to his Holiness in early August to appoint a representative to participate in the committee that selected the judges for the talks. The statement said that though Pope Francis supported the peace process, he, however, reiterated that he would not get involved in Colombian peace deal. It said that Pope was praying for the enlightenment of the hearts and minds of those who were called to promote the common good of the Colombian nation. A deal was announced last week, putting an end to five decades of internal conflict between government forces and the FARC rebels. The agreement, which needed to be ratified through a referendum in Oct. 2, would entail setting up a special court to grant amnesties or pu...
Post a Comment
Read more

Man docked for defiling 9-year-old girl

magistrate-court A 33-year-old man, Godwin Otobo, was on Monday docked at a Surulere Chief Magistrates’ Court in Lagos.For allegedly defiling a nine-year-old girl, ‎Otobo, who lives at No. 10, Borrow Pit St., Sangotedo-Ajah area of Lagos, was said to have defiled the underage girl whose parents also reside in the same compound. The Prosecutor, Sgt. Anthonia Osayande, told the court that the accused committed the offence at about 9.00 p.m. sometimes in September. “The accused defiled the girl in the night when she was fetching water.‎ “The offence contravened Section 137 of the Criminal Law of Lagos State, 2011,’’ Osayande told the court. The accused pleaded not guilty to the one-count charge of defilement. Ruling on a bail application filed by the accused, Chief Magistrate Ipaye Nwachukwu, granted him bail in the sum of N500,000 with two sureties in like sum. She said one of the sureties must be a property owner in Lagos State, while the other must be a civil servant on grade...
Post a Comment
Read more